whos the better QB Kerry Joseph or Casey Printers?

lets see everyone..
Name Year Team Att Comp % Yards Long TD % Int % Rating
Printers 2008 HAM 101 65 64.4 854 54 0 0.0 3 3.0 78.6
JOSEPH, K 2008 TOR 126 74 58.7 839 90 3 2.4 3 2.4 76.8

considering that printers can only throw short passes,he's attempted maybe a couple long passes and cant even throw a touchdown.

lets talk about Joseph player,against Edmonton he had a game-high 118 yards rushing. Joseph was 22-of-38 passing for 343 yards and a TD. he may not have had a good couple first games that's because he had to get to know the coaching staff,players and new plays. considering Joesph led last year in the CFL in rushing with 700 yards and is the most valuable player,won Grey cup

who would you rather have as a QB Joseph or Printers?

Right now? I'd take Joseph.

I think Printers needs a little more time to find his groove.

I'm not entirely certain that Printers will EVER find his groove.

When things go awry, he looks very helpless and despondent.

A guy who has yet to throw a TD pass this season is not a complete QB in my opinion. Printers may yet come around but today, I'd take Joseph.

An Argo-Cat fan

Alright....allow me to be the first one to stick up for our guy. I'd take Printers!

Casey has the tools to be the best QB in the CFL.....oh yeah and lets not forget, he was the best QB in the CFL a few years ago before rotting on an NFL practice squad for two seasons.

I love his passion and determination. He wants to be the leader of this team and he wants to win....bad! That and he's willing to shoulder the blame and be up front with everyone, just like he does on his radio show EVERY week!

As for this: "considering that printers can only throw short passes,he's attempted maybe a couple long passes and cant even throw a touchdown."

That's a well thought out argument. You should write a book.

He might not have a TD pass yet but that's because we're running the ball so much. (Don't forget his 4 rushing TD's which is tied for second in the entire league...RB's included.) His passing TD's will come. This whole team has to get better as a unit, but if you want to point fingers right now, Casey and the O is not the problem.

Nothing against Joseph because I like him too, but I'll take our guy.

Well said AMG, :thup:

Printers has shown that he wants to win here. He has a very positive attitude and the guy plays his heart out. ( prime ie, that run in the Calgary game. He took the hit, head on. Got up quick. That says it all right there. The guy is trying!!!)

I really believe he is going to have a stellar game against the Eskimoes!!!

I understand why ticat fans need to beleive in printers. I have mixed feelings.

On one hand, I would prefer printers to prove my reservations about him right so that williams could end up as starter

OTOH - tican fans, especially caretaker, deserve to see printers and co live up to their expectations.

Godd thing I dont have to decide. Its all up to Printers.

I like them both!!
Why do we have these silly topics?
and why do I comment on these silly topics?

Short term id say kerry joesph is the one id pick long term if u want a qb to build a team around cp he is younger.

id take KJ-4 for right now...but if im building with plans of a dynasty, thats casey printers.

casey will be great for a long long time, well after KJ-4 is retired.

I'm relieved to see FootballYouBet finally weigh in with his opinion on Printers. I've been in suspense in case you'd changed your mind from the previous 100 times you did so.

But I digress. I just wanted to mention a stat I heard during the Calgary game the other night. I thought they said that Hamilton had scored a TD 6 out of the 10 times they had been in the red zone this season. After 2 more scores in that game, they would be 8 for 10. All were rushing TDs, obviously.

I'm going to guess that most of the coaches in the league would take those odds in a second even if it meant their QB would not throw for another TD pass all season. Why would you take the risks involved in a throw when your ground game is such a sure thing? (Although we do seem to have particular difficulty once we reach the one yard line.)

Anyway, now all we have to do is sustain drives long enough to get to the red zone a little more often.

Anyway, now all we have to do is sustain drives long enough to get to the red zone a little more often.
aye, there's the rub

What makes Printers any different from this quote????

And you wait for Joseph to have his best game of the year to compare? I guess Printers' 4 rushing TD's are garbage too eh?

Just for this season? KJ.

Printers hasn't impressed me at all. Looks terrible when he doesn't have the running game to fall back on. Although, this may be partly Bellfeuille's crappy system's fault.

I thnk “terrible” is overstating it.

Looks more rsuty to me. I really think reps will help him.

He has ability, it’s the fundamentals that are lacking (looking off, touch on the ball, stepping up in the pocket, happy feet).

Reps should cure that, and once they do, watch out.

Captain Kirk wrote,

I thnk "terrible" is overstating it.

Looks more rsuty to me. I really think reps will help him.

He has ability, it's the fundamentals that are lacking (looking off, touch on the ball, stepping up in the pocket, happy feet).

Reps should cure that, and once they do, watch out.


I agree with your assessment Captain.

I believe Printers has the athleticism, and talent. He just has to get more playing time. Sometimes people forget he has only played one full season in the C.F.L with a very talented B.C Lion team.

I think minor mistakes such as rushing passes and running back 15 yards, instead of stepping up in the pocket can be fixed. McManus is the coach to teach him. Once he gets some confidence and a calming influence he is going to be a very dangerous QB.

What’s the point of this thread? Were you just sitting there and decided to drum up some stupid pointless debate about two qb’s on struggling teams? It’s totally irrelevant. Obviously this author has something to prove. I’m just blown away by the stupidity of this thread.

Are you guys all nuts? I'd take Printers hands down.

Geez, Joseph has one good game and you people are all prepared to make him the Pope!

Whats the point of this forum if not to discuss such things as a comparison of 2 recent MOP QBs?? Were you just sitting there and decided to drum up some stupid pointless criticism about a perfectly reasonable topic? Talk about irrelevant. Obviously you must have something to prove. I'm just blown away by the stupidity of your post.