OK...at the risk of being accused of fomenting a quarterback controversy...I'm wondering what people think.
Naturally some will say it's not a fair comparison. On the one hand you have a young quarterback with almost zero CFL experience, only a few practices under his belt after a fairly serious injury...and on the other hand a seasoned veteran coming off a serious injury himself.
McPherson threw for over 250 yards and ran for over 120...Calvillo broke 300 yards passing and...well you know...
Calvillo beat a bottom feeding team, down on it's luck, McPherson beat a Hamilton team that would have climbed into a tie for 1st place for the 1st time in....how long?
So...despite the possible consequences....and before Anthony plays his next game and makes the whole question moot...as comeback 1st starts after an injury etc....Who Had The Better Start?