When you say “broadcasters”, do you mean the stadium announcer? Because on television, both Rod Black and Proulx’s voices can be heard addressing this play.
I get not hearing it in the stadium, but on my DVR first you hear Rod Black talking about how whether there is a point or not will depend on whether it was touched, then you hear Proulx announce: “Ball went through goal without being touched. There is no score on the play. First down on the twenty-five yard line.” That doesn’t mean it was the right call, but the TV broadcast left no mystery as to what call was made.
What pissed me off was that they couldn’t give a number for the alleged illegal block (or was it alleged holding?) on the Banks TD that was called back, though Forde had his theory.
Perhaps the official twenty or thirty feet away could actually tell without a doubt that the Montreal player didn’t touch the ball. (Novel concept?) It didn’t look like he even considered dropping his hand to start the clock.
I remember that play. Looked like a pretty blatant unnecessary roughness penalty to me. If i remember it correctly, a bunch of guys were standing around a pile near the end of a play, when Simmons came along and just decked a guy for no apparent reason.