Should video review be changed ?

I'm with Arius....get rid of replay. I think the officials are more tenative than prior to instant replay.

Penalties are judgements. What if you challenge a lined up off side? How does a replay offical bring out a tape measure to a TV monitor? What about an illegal block? thats half from the side and half from the back, then what?

A coach would have to be very careful in what call he should challenge, unless it obvious that the call was missed. Its been said already but you dont need to raise the number of challenges, just allow one penalty call to be challenged. If the officials know that a call could be challenged, maybe they dont get flag happy. Its happening too many times for some of change not to be made.

If the league wanted to include penalities the rules should be same as any other reviewable play.