Opinion on Overall Ratings for CFLing Maximum Football 2018

Hey all,
Just wanting to get an idea of if I am on the right track for the Overall rating in a CFL video game version of Maximum Football

Here are the QBs:

[tr][td]BC[/td]
[td]Danny[/td]
[td]O’Brien[/td]
[td]69[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]BC[/td]
[td]Brandon[/td]
[td]Bridge[/td]
[td]78[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]BC[/td]
[td]Mike[/td]
[td]Reilly[/td]
[td]90[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]CGY[/td]
[td]Montell[/td]
[td]Cozart[/td]
[td]65[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]CGY[/td]
[td]Bo Levi[/td]
[td]Mitchell[/td]
[td]91[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]EDM[/td]
[td]Jeremiah[/td]
[td]Briscoe[/td]
[td]64[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]EDM[/td]
[td]Logan[/td]
[td]Kilgore[/td]
[td]79[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]EDM[/td]
[td]Trevor[/td]
[td]Harris[/td]
[td]91[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]HAM[/td]
[td]David[/td]
[td]Watford[/td]
[td]73[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]HAM[/td]
[td]Hayden[/td]
[td]Moore[/td]
[td]74[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]HAM[/td]
[td]Dane[/td]
[td]Evans[/td]
[td]85[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]HAM[/td]
[td]Jeremiah[/td]
[td]Masoli[/td]
[td]89[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]MTL[/td]
[td]Antonio[/td]
[td]Pipkin[/td]
[td]75[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]MTL[/td]
[td]Matthew[/td]
[td]Shiltz[/td]
[td]79[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]MTL[/td]
[td]Vernon[/td]
[td]Adams[/td]
[td]85[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]OTT[/td]
[td]William[/td]
[td]Arndt[/td]
[td]73[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]OTT[/td]
[td]Nick[/td]
[td]Arbuckle[/td]
[td]79[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]OTT[/td]
[td]Jonathon[/td]
[td]Jennings[/td]
[td]81[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]OTT[/td]
[td]Dominiquw[/td]
[td]Davis[/td]
[td]89[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]SSK[/td]
[td]Bryan[/td]
[td]Bennett[/td]
[td]67[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]SSK[/td]
[td]Isaac[/td]
[td]Harker[/td]
[td]74[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]SSK[/td]
[td]Cody[/td]
[td]Fajardo[/td]
[td]89[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]TOR[/td]
[td]Dakota[/td]
[td]Prukop[/td]
[td]74[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]TOR[/td]
[td]James[/td]
[td]Franklin[/td]
[td]77[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]TOR[/td]
[td]Macleod[/td]
[td]Bethal Thompson[/td]
[td]88[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]TOR[/td]
[td]Michael[/td]
[td]O’Connor[/td]
[td]65[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]WPG[/td]
[td]Sean[/td]
[td]McGuire[/td]
[td]65[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]WPG[/td]
[td]Chris[/td]
[td]Streveler[/td]
[td]81[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]WPG[/td]
[td]Matt[/td]
[td]Nichols[/td]
[td]85[/td]
[/tr]
[tr][td]WPG[/td]
[td]Zach[/td]
[td]Collaros[/td]
[td]87[/td]
[/tr]

Opinions???

How does O’Connor rank an 88?

Typing error now that I look… he shows as 65

not too bad overall, but Nick Arbuckle showed enough last year that he has no business being rated lower than a scrub like Jennings. There shouldn’t be a 10 point disparity between Arbuckle & Fajardo, Arbuckle had the higher QB rating in 2019.

I’d have Dom Davis at around 74 on this scale.

I don’t know if you have used some sort of methodology, but overhall it seems legit. I think however that Dominique Davis, Logan Kilgore and MacBeth are rated highter than they should be (maybe between 80-83 for MacBeth, around 75 for Kilgore and lower than 80 for Davis). I would also put Reilly at the top, or at least equal to the top, because of his toughness and strengh habilities that Mithcell and Harris don’t necessarly have.

Schiltz is slightly over-rated and Pipken even more … using Adams as my benchmark … also over-rated are Bridge, Jennings, Davis, Franklin and Bethel-Thompson … some more than others

All comments are appreciated. All positions in the game determine Overall slightly different.

I was able to get MOST players combine ratings, and used what appears to be a legit conversion used for Madden ratings, so in the case of QBs the ratings are based on 4 things:

  1. Speed (Comes from Combine and really cant be changed)
  2. Intelligence - Which I used experience to generate, but think it is not wholly accurate
  3. Throw Accuracy and Power, which the current stats were used to determine based on games played and QB stats.

Keep the comments coming! It is appreciated

#2 is the problem (IMO) … Bridge is an example of a QB with experience that does not show good on-field decision making … same for, for example, Pipken and Jennings

My take.

BC Mike Reilly 91
BC Brandon Bridge 75
CGY Bo Levi Mitchell 90
EDM Logan Kilgore 75
EDM Trevor Harris 87
HAM Dane Evans 84
HAM Jeremiah Masoli 86
MTL Antonio Pipkin 75
MTL Matthew Shiltz 75
MTL Vernon Adams 84
OTT William Arndt 73
OTT Nick Arbuckle 83
OTT Jonathon Jennings 77
OTT Dominique Davis 74
SSK Isaac Harker 74
SSK Cody Fajardo 85
TOR James Franklin 75
TOR Macleod Bethal Thompson 82
WPG Chris Streveler 79
WPG Matt Nichols 83
WPG Zach Collaros 84