McLeod Bethel-Thompson vs Nick Arbuckle

Who's the better starting QB considering MacBeth has a better arm but Arbuckle is great in the current system of dinking and dunking consistently moving the chains in a league where you don't always get penalized for interceptions.

  • MacLeod Bethel-Thompson
  • Nick Arbuckle

0 voters

1 Like

I voted Arbuckle, but I think it's close.

MBT might have a slightly stronger arm, but he often has trouble figuring out range and timing.

2 Likes

Arbuckle. But I also like MBT. I think they both have potential.

2 Likes

Sometimes I'm under the illusion that Macbeth will figure it out in which case there's only upside. You're right though, sometimes his throws might be a little late or a bit off target. But if you're playing from behind and need to catch up I think it's MBT all the way.

1 Like

I would like to see Arbuckle throw deep passes more than twice a game to reach that potential. I'm not sure he has the arm strength to do it though.

1 Like

True. I think he reads defences a little better, and has a strong enough arm.

3 Likes