Wow Bobo you did it again! This is more of the kind of strategically creative thinking we need around here and leadership in national capitals too I figure.
Will Ferrell once referred to it as "strategery" I do believe, but I digress.
How about a sumo suit face off 5-on-5 guys plus give them boxing gloves? No holds barred - they have protection after all!
Although this is a good idea, it's not happening for reasons cited above. None of those making these decisions wants at least one more quarter of football instead of a chance for the game to end earlier.
All 3 are equally bad ways to end a game. Overtime should not be a modified version of the game. Shorter quarters/periods sure. But 3 on 3? Shoot outs? Coins? If fans can't stomach another few minutes of a sport they claim to like then decide all overtime games in every sport with a game of darts. And if darts can go in to overtime - make them play cribbage.
In the regular season, it would be a different kettle of fish, but in the playoffs, my solution is:
One five-minute OT session to determine the winner. Conducted just like regular 60 minutes except it's 5 minutes long. If at the end of that session, the game is still tied, play another 5 minutes. And then another. Eventually someone will be the winner.
Each get two possessions no matter how they are achieved kickoff , punt , fumble , INT , loss of downs .
If They are still tied ....
they each get one more possession until they eventually have a winner by the score .
like baseball scoring .
And yes it maybe possible within the first two possessions the second possession of the second team will have to concede if the first two possessions resulted in more than 8 points ahead .
I would also run those 5-minute OT sessions 100% as if you're inside the 2-minute warning at the end of a half. Hurry-up offense. Get the ball spotted quickly, get the play off, or you're toast. Heighten the stakes. The better-prepared and/or better-conditioned players will shine.
Might work great if you can convince the nhl guys to move forward toward the opposing goal like i'm sure the kids did. Problem is, 3 on 3 nhl overtime looks like soccer. They are going backwards or passing backwards most of the period. It's garbage - play darts instead!!