Actually, I REALLY like the idea of an official Game of the Year. It could be replayed after The Grey Cup, maybe on New Year's day. Fans could vote on it from a list of 3 or 4 games chosen by the players, coaches, and reporters. The Play of the Year could be highlighted during the game.
That Calgary-Edmonton rematch was a fantastic game, with the hail Mary at the end that just missed. It's not often I get excited watching replays, but there were several plays in that game that actually increased my heart rate — Romar Morris's 75 yard run from scrimmage was one of them.