Deal or no deal?

If you could go back one year, but knowing what you do now of both players. Would you trade Troy Davis straight up for Tay Cody?

Tay Cody, Thats a dumb question he is a beast.

No deal. Dumb question. Go to bed.

No deal.

Love Tay...but Troy Davis is STILL an outstanding back.

Deal. Dumb question. Go to bed

:lol:

definatley would

Deal. Wouldn't have to think about it. Troy's talent is slowly declining (he's getting older), Tay is just reaching his prime. Plus, theres more talented running backs out there than talented defensive backs.

Deal

Deal!

How much did I win Howie?

both are superlative players, no doubt, and we were lucky to have them both. however, i would keep troy — and would try mightily to get tay — and get them both on the same team.
both are quintessential tiger-cats.
i think, as far as the 2005 season went, and what we knew at the time, i would rather have kept troy davis.
(and traded the rights to devon finn/chris martin/craig yeast/whover/mark moroz/ to get tay.)
here's a tay cody trivia question: what did tay cody do on his first play in the cfl? (intercepted a danny mcmanus pass!)

here's a tay cody trivia question: what did tay cody do on his first play in the cfl? (intercepted a danny mcmanus pass!)
Who didn't???