Choose Your CFL All-Star Team Starting Line up!!

Ok. lets say you were hired as the Head Coach for the CFL All-Star team that would take on the NFL..

(lets leave the cfl vs nfl crap out) just pick the best players for each of the 26 positions!!

only 1 player per Spot

QB - 1
RB - 2
REC - 4
O-Line - 5

D-Line - 4
LB - 3
DB - 4
S - 1

K - 1
P - 1

So post your starting players for Each spot, of the Current CFL Rosters, injured or Not.

Well Sean Millington apparently doesn’t even need the rest of a team!

Quarterback: Ricky Ray
RB 1 : Joe Smith
RB 2 : Joffery Reynolds
WR 1 : Geroy Simon
WR 2 : Matt Dominguez
WR 3 : Derick Armstrong
WR 4 : Nik Lewis
C : Angus Reid
G : Rob Murphy
G : Gene Makowsky
T : Jeremy O'Day
T : Matt Sheridan

DT : Doug Brown
DT : Fred Perry
DE : Brent Johnson
DE : Gavin Walls
LB : Kevin Eiben
LB : Brian Clarke
LB : Reggie Hunt
DB : Byron Parker
DB : Eddie Davis
DB : Ryan Phillips
DB : Kelly Malveaux
S : Barron Miles

K : Noel Prefontaine
P : Jamie Borahm

KR : Aron Smart

There were a lot of people out there that possibly could have started too, but some things were Age, size and experience that made the choices

Quarterback: Ricky Ray
RB 1 : Charles Roberts
RB 2 : Joe Smith
WR 1 : Milt Stegall
WR 2 : Geroy Simon
WR 3 : Terrence Edwards
WR 4 : Kerry Watkins
C : Obby Khan
G : Rob Murphy
G : Gene Makowsky
T : Dan Goodspeed
T : Matt Sheridan

DT : Doug Brown
DT : Fred Perry
DE : Brent Johnson
DE : Gavin Walls
LB : Kevin Eiben
LB : Barrin Simpson
LB : Reggie Hunt
DB : Byron Parker
DB : Juran Bolden
DB : Ryan Phillips
DB : Kelly Malveaux
S : Barron Miles/ Kyries Hebert

K : Sandro DeAngelis
P : Burke Dales

KR : Ian Smart

Before choosing my team, I would need to know if it was going to be CFL rules on a CFL field, or, NFL rules on a NFL field.

doesn't matter.

Can't argue much with either list. Wonder though is Tyrone Williams better than Doug Brown? Alot of people in BC think he is the best D Linemen on the team and rarely recognized as such, takes alot of the double teams freeing up Brent Johnson and Cameron Wake.

doesn't matter.
Sure it does.

If we are playing CFL rules and field, I would choose a more quick and agile team.

However, if we were playing with NFL rules and field, I would choose a bigger and stronger team.

does it have to be players still playing??

Don't know all the positions that well, so my team would be a little scarce. :lol:

But if you're going with Ray at QB, which is a smart pick, then you need Jason Tucker at WR. Get the two of them on the field together and fuggetaboutit.

there are other players than Tucker that can do it!

But Tucker probably has the best chemistry with Ray.

NFL Field.

Quarterback: Ricky Ray
RB 1 : Joe Smith
RB 2 : Joffery Reynolds
WR 1 : Geroy Simon
WR 2 : Matt Dominguez
WR 3 : Jason Clermont
WR 4 : Nik Lewis
C : Angus Reid
G : Rob Murphy
G : Gene Makowsky
T : Jeremy O'Day
T : Matt Sheridan

DT : Doug Brown
DT : Fred Perry
DE : Brent Johnson
DE : Gavin Walls
LB : Kevin Eiben
LB : Brian Clarke
LB : Reggie Hunt
DB : Byron Parker
DB : Juran Bolden
DB : Ryan Phillips
DB : Eddie Davis
S : Barron Miles

K : Sandro DeAngelis
P : Jamie Borahm

KR : Aron Smart

CFL field:

QB: Ray out Burris in
RB: Reynolds out Roberts in
R: Clermont out Tucker in
DT: Brown out Williams in

Wider field would benefit from significantly more mobility while the smaller field needs more bulk.

Some pretty decent lists so far, except Fred Perry is a DE and would be severely undersize for a DT.

For me, based on this season...

QUARTERBACK
Ricky Ray

RUNNING BACKS
Charles Robert
Joe Smith

RECEIVERS:
Milt Stegal
Ben Cahoon
Jason Clermont
Jason Tucker

O-LINE:
C: Brian Chiu
G : Rob Murphy
G : Gene Makowsky
T : Jeremy O'Day
T : Matt Sheridan

D-LINE
DE : Fred Perry
DE : Brent Johnson
DT : Doug Brown
DT : Dario Romero

LINEBACKERS:
Zeke Moreno
Barrin Simpson
Reggie Hunt

DEFENSIVE BACKS:
Korey Banks
Randee Drew
Tay Cody
Byron Parker

SAFETY:
Barron Miles

KICKER:
Luca Congi

PUNTER:
Damon Duval

RETURNER:
Dominic Dorsey

Why does everyone think Makowsky is a guard and O'Day is a tackle. Geno's a tackle and O'Day's a centre for chrissake. At least pick guys in their proper positions.

does it have to be players still playing??