CFLPA Report Cards

https://3downnation.com/2024/12/17/cflpa-unveils-inaugural-cfl-team-report-card-results/

Hamilton earned the top grade overall.

Football Ops had our lowest grade, and second-lowest throughout the League; although Dyakowski mentioned that "there are some rough correlations with on-field success, which shouldn’t be a big surprise.” That can mean a few things - that a team that grades low doesn’t support the players enough to succeed, the players were upset over a losing season, the confusion about new ownership in Edmonton (lots of places for improvement), for example.

The rest of our grades were fairly good.

2 Likes

Very interesting. Thanks for posting. :v:

2 Likes

Biggest surprise to me is BC on the low end even with Doman’s money and influence. Expected Wpg and Argos to be a bit higher.

A summary of the report cards:

2 Likes

Management and Admin may be due to the VAJ/Rourke thing, among others. The practice facility is in poor condition, according to one respondent. Maybe all the owner’s money has gone into the fans’ experience (concerts and the like) and marketing rather than facilities (City-owned?) and silly things like player’s nutrition.

2 Likes

Not surprising!
Ticats are #1
Caretaker wouldn’t have it any other way.

Hamilton Tiger-Cats — B (3.00)
Saskatchewan Roughriders — B (3.00)
Ottawa Redblacks — B- (2.83)
Winnipeg Blue Bombers — B- (2.79)
Toronto Argonauts — B- (2.67)
Montreal Alouettes — C+ (2.25)
Calgary Stampeders — C- (1.75)
B.C. Lions — C- (1.67)
Edmonton Elks — D+ (1.46)

2 Likes

The only thing I am embarssed about as a ticat fan is the way the one player said how fans treat players fans. Me Personally where i sit, I always see players families if game hasnt started i always introduce myself or if they are behind me at a away game always make them feel welcome.

3 Likes

Nutrition and diet for the rest of the league is atrocious. What are teams feeding their players? KFC, Taco Bell and McDonalds. :smile:

Somebody mentioned cold pizza…

Honestly, proper nutrition is just as important for athletes as proper training facilities, proper medical and recovery, proper coaching…

3 Likes

I think this all looks pretty good on the Cats organization today.
Now let’s build THE team.

Edit: except for “Football Operations”

1 Like

I hope our Head Coach, New GM and most importantly President of Football Operations take the score in Football Operations seriously.

2 Likes

Hopefully our high score helps recruit free agents.

3 Likes

My fan report card:
Winning
Commitment To Winning
In/Out Privileges.

But what does it actually mean? Is it a big picture or just a snapshot ? Last season aside has bad report card CAL, for example, ever had trouble attracting, retaining talent and FAs ?

1 Like

Calgary 2012-2022 vs Calgary 2023-2024 are two completely different stories.
It’s a snapshot of the big picture of 2024
( if that makes any sense)

1 Like

A snapshot of the moment lessens the significance and importance of report cards, then.

C- MTL was the class of the East and only in-game circumstances, not off field niceties , stopped them from going and possibly winning the GC again.

1 Like

But it’s both.
Its how players feel during the 2024 season, and its a result of what was already in place, ( equipment, meals, training facilities, training camp).
It is relevant in the sense that players talk and money is , more or less, the same for each team, so going into Free Agency, these reports could influence decisions.
The fact that the Cats missed the playoffs and only won 7 games and still finished on top of the grades is significant I think.
I’m also aware that, in some cases, a winning record and playoff bonuses have a bigger impact on a player’s decisions then a team’s meal plan.

4 Likes

It certainly appears to me that
"Football Operations " just had a huge change in the hiring of Goveia as a stand alone GM instead of the clusterfuk commitee chain of command where everyone and no one were held responsible for decisions that was before
:point_left:
:point_right:
:point_up_2:
:point_down:

1 Like

Fabulous interview with CFLPA 's Peter Dyakowski
on the report card

2 Likes

All report cards are just a snapshot. I’m not sure how you don’t understand that.
Every single report card ever in existence is a snapshot of things at that time. Yet they determined my academic path.
In Grade 8, I was great at math. Grade 9 a little less. Grade 10 worse. Grade 11 barely passed. Each one was a snapshot of how I was doing at that point in time. As you can see, I got progressively worse in math and it threw my career as a meteorologist right out the window.

3 Likes