True, but those receivers are all gone, and yet Calvillo is still looking good. His reads are almost perfect, he throws the ball quickly and most of the time right on target. Yeah, he does throw the occasional int, but it’s rare, and most of those are because the receiver is out of position, not because he threw badly. That’s the wonderful thing about football, you can actually tell when you’re watching who is screwing up, the QB or the receiver. I have rarely seen AC make a bad pass in the last 8 years. Other QB’s, even so-called great ones like Ray & Burris make bad passes on a more regular basis. Guys like Durrant and Lulay do so more often, and only good receivers make them look great. The rest of the pack, well, they really are pretty mediocre QB’s. Consistency, that’s what makes a great QB, IMO. AC has that, the rest don’t.
The QB who looks good with bad receivers does not exist. EVERY great QB in history has had good receivers. Just look on the weekend, the QBs that looked good also had guys making plays for them. Stretching out for passes, taking hits and hanging on, and in one case pulling it down in double or triple coverage. On bad teams? Those are incompletions or picks. They call this a team sport for a reason: QBs are only as good as the guys catching the passes.
Lemon didn’t have them. Jyles doesn’t have them. It’s not surprising at all that the Toronto offense looks the same: except for one guy it IS the same. People who expect miracles are delusional. When they get a legit #1 receiver then we’ll talk.
Well, I think guys like Flutie, Moon, and several others were QB’s who could make receivers look good and AC is in that group. No one else is in the current crop of CFL QB’s. I can’t speak for the NFL 'cause I refuse to watch it.