A minus for the NFL..IMO

I really hate this NFL alternative to the onside kick proposal

But if they are going to do it, not having the trailing requirement would be a small positive to original proposal.

1 Like

I have no clue why they could not keep, if only for a maximum of 3 plays per game in regulation only, the old rules for players lining up behind the kicker and that solves this made-up problem.

I do not favour such a gimmick.

I do think some of the XFL kickoff rules, not the punts, ought be examined.