The funny thing is that collectively we have shown the worst in the last 3 years since I have been involved. We also showed poorly against the writers as habitually many of us beat all of them. I attribute that to there being much more parity in the league this year and the picks being much harder than in the last couple of years.
Two years ago here are the stats with the winner having 60 picks correct:
Last year the winner had 62 picks correct:
I think that clearly this year was tougher to pick. An interesting comparison nonetheless.